I'm In Love With Mothman, Paige Lavoie

$24.00 USD

Sale Sold out

Taxes included. Shipping calculated at checkout.

22-year-old Heather is suffering from an epic case of burnout.

So, just like any other young influencer, she

abandons her social platforms. Check!

gathers up her best flowy dresses. Check!

and moves to a desolate cabin. Check!

Heather imagines spending her #unplugged days traipsing through the woods and tending to her garden. However, her cottagecore fantasy is turned upside down when a wounded cryptid crashes into her roof—and her heart.

With no help from her internet followers, and the local monster-hunter growing suspicious, Heather’s quiet life in the wilderness has suddenly become a little more complicated. To make matters worse, she thinks she might be falling in love with the brooding winged man in her living room.

Important Order Information

We’re a small shop, which means its impossible to stock/re-stock every title listed—but don’t worry, we still want you to get the books you love. You can order any title, and it’ll come straight from our distributor warehouse in about 2–4 weeks with priority service at time of distributor processing not at time of order.

Note: Unreleased titles ship on release day. Thanks for your patience. We look forward to your order!

Once your order is on its way, we’ll send you tracking information, and we’ll also send an SMS or email when it’s ready for pickup in the shop. Thanks for supporting our little hole in the wall—we can’t wait for you to get your hands on your next favorite read!

Just so you know, if we don’t carry the book you’re looking for, we also have a request page here.

Love Club Member (LCM) Perks

Love Club Members are eligible for a 60% precent down payment until the arrival of the item. Additionally, members earn 2x points per $1 instead of the standard 1.5x per $1. Including a 5% daily discount.

** some conditions may apply.
** see for more details here.

Book cover type Paperback Hardcover

View full details

Let customers speak for us

from 26 reviews

Josilyn

"Probably Reading" Detachable Magnetic Kindle Case

Love it

Definitely worth the buy for a new kindle case!! ❤️❤️

05/27/2026

April Nicole Tibajares

Transparent Clear Kindle Case

Popular Clear Case

very friendly and always makes you feel comfortable enough to stay and go. Love the vibes!!

05/04/2026

Raina Bunz

Blind Date with a Book | Special Order | Book Lover Gift

24hr Turn Around

She is actually sold out but I requested a special order as her bestie weeks in advanced and she created my BDWAB in 24hrs before pick up! Amazing customer service!!!

04/29/2026

Cee

Chaotic, Shantel Tessier

10/10 book.

By far, my 2nd favorite spade brother ❤️ this book had me in a chokehold. The themes in this book are not for the faint of heart, please read the trigger warnings. I can say hands down, that this bookhad me taking breaks because it was THAT heavy. I loved it, cover to cover.

04/28/2026

Cee

The Smut Syndicate

Always a pleasure shopping with Kat.

I always have a fun experience when shoppingat Smut Syndicate. It gives me great joy to walk into that safe space.

04/20/2026

April Nicole Tibajares

E-Reader Kindle Case

Lucky last one!🙏🏼

Lucky last one — finally found on island a case that fits my old kindle! 🥰😍🔥🙏🏼

04/01/2026